Open Face Mashed Potato Stuffed Turkey MeatballsÂ
Comfort food just leveled up with these Open-Face Mashed Potato Stuffed Turkey Meatballs — juicy turkey meatballs filled with creamy mashed potatoes and served like the ultimate fork-and-knife bite. It’s everything you love about a classic turkey dinner, reinvented into one cozy, crave-worthy masterpiece.
If Thanksgiving leftovers had a glow-up, this would be it. These Open-Face Mashed Potato Stuffed Turkey Meatballs take all the cozy, nostalgic flavors of a classic turkey dinner and turn them into juicy, flavor-packed bites that are perfect any time of year — no holiday required.
Each meatball is filled with creamy mashed potatoes and served open-face for maximum comfort food impact, especially when topped with rich gravy or a drizzle of butter. It’s hearty, satisfying, and just a little bit indulgent — the kind of meal that makes you want seconds before you’ve even finished your first plate.
Open Face Mashed Potato Stuffed Turkey Meatballs
Ingredients
For the Meatballs
- 1 lb ground turkey
- 1 cup plain breadcrumbs
- 1 tbs dry parsley
- 1 tbs dry thyme
- 1 tbs dry rosemary
- 1 tbs dry sage
- 2 eggs
- salt & pepper to taste
For the Gravy
- 2 cups turkey or chicken broth
- 2 tbs flour
- 2 tbs butter
Instructions
For the Meatballs
- Preheat the oven to 350 degrees Fahrenheit
- In a bowl combine ground turkey, breadcrumbs, eggs, parsley, sage, rosemary, and thyme. Season to taste salt and pepper.
- Take the meat mixture and flatten in the palm of your hand.Â
- Take one of the frozen mashed potato pucks and place it in the middle of the flattened meat mixture in the middle of your hand.
- Wrap the meat mixture around the frozen mashed potato puck and gently roll it in your hand to form a ball.
- Place the meatballs on a greased and/or tin foil-lined baking sheet.
- Bake the meatballs in the preheated oven for 23 minutes.
Open-faced turkey sandwiches have long been a staple of American comfort food, especially throughout the Midwest and Northeast. Often served in diners and small-town cafés, this classic dish typically features slices of roasted turkey piled over bread, topped with creamy mashed potatoes, and finished with a generous ladle of savory gravy. It’s simple, hearty, and deeply nostalgic — the kind of meal that feels like it’s been warming plates (and souls) for generations.
The roots of the open-faced sandwich trace back to early European dining traditions, where bread was commonly used as a base for meats and sauces rather than a handheld vessel. In the United States, the concept evolved into diner favorites like hot turkey sandwiches and hot beef sandwiches, often served with gravy as a way to stretch ingredients and create a filling, affordable meal. Over time, it became a post-Thanksgiving icon, giving new life to leftover turkey, mashed potatoes, and gravy in the most delicious way possible.
These Open-Face Mashed Potato Stuffed Turkey Meatballs take that classic concept and give it a modern, meatball-loving twist. Instead of layering turkey and potatoes separately, we tuck creamy mashed potatoes right inside seasoned ground turkey, creating a built-in comfort food surprise. It’s like the best part of the plate got rolled into one perfect bite — efficient, delicious, and honestly kind of genius.
From a texture standpoint, this recipe is doing the most (in the best way). The turkey meatballs stay juicy and tender, while the mashed potato center adds a creamy, almost buttery contrast that melts into the meat as it cooks. When served open-face over bread and topped with gravy, you get that familiar fork-and-knife experience — soft, savory, and completely satisfying — but with a fun, unexpected upgrade.
This recipe hits all the comfort food keywords people are craving: turkey meatballs, mashed potato stuffed meatballs, open-faced turkey sandwich, Thanksgiving leftovers recipe, and easy cozy dinner ideas. It’s perfect for using up leftovers, planning a comforting weeknight meal, or creating a crowd-pleasing dish that feels both familiar and new. Bonus: it’s freezer-friendly and reheats beautifully, making it a great make-ahead option.
At its core, this recipe is all about taking something classic and making it more playful, more versatile, and — let’s be honest — more meatball-forward. It honors the history of the open-faced turkey sandwich while giving you a dish that feels fresh, creative, and incredibly satisfying. Because if there’s one thing we believe around here, it’s that comfort food should never be boring — and meatballs make everything better.
Can I use leftover mashed potatoes for stuffed meatballs?
Yes! Leftover mashed potatoes work perfectly in this recipe. Just make sure they’re chilled and firm enough to scoop so they hold their shape when stuffing the meatballs.
What is the best way to serve open-face turkey meatballs?
Serve them over toasted bread or Texas toast, topped with warm gravy for that classic open-faced sandwich feel. You can also add cranberry sauce for a full Thanksgiving-inspired bite.
What kind of gravy works best with this recipe?
A classic turkey or brown gravy works best, but you can also use chicken gravy for a lighter option. Homemade gravy will give the richest flavor, but store-bought works great for convenience.
Can I make this recipe gluten-free?
Yes, simply swap the breadcrumbs for gluten-free breadcrumbs and serve over gluten-free bread. The rest of the ingredients are naturally gluten-friendly depending on your gravy choice.
More Recipes By Category
Midwestern Meatballs
We live in the Midwest and there are so many classic recipes that the rest of the country is missing out on. I'm here to help share those recipes in meatball form.
Classic Meatballs
I have some classic meatballs that are the foundation of a lot of my meatball recipes. You'll find some basic meatball recipes and recipes that we are grew up with and love.
Stuffed Meatballs
I love stuffing meatballs - and once you start browsing the site you'll see that I'm pretty creative with what I can come up with to stuff my balls with - and every recipe is delicious.
